Knowledge Base

Overview
Inspection & Test Plans

The Seven Verification Verdicts

Handoverhandoververificationverdictsevidencesign-off
Carlos Greblo - Updated 04 Aug 2026

Claim against evidence

Every requirement in the project gets one verdict, from two inputs:

•

The claim is the requirement's Status.

•

The evidence is the ITP items linked to it, with their Result and who signed off.

A verdict states how the two compare. The same seven values run the page, the report and the workbook.

The seven verdicts

VerdictWhat it meansWhat to do
ContradictedA linked check records a failClose the defect out, re-inspect, then set the item's Result
UnsubstantiatedClaimed verified, no linked check passedLink the ITP item that proves it, or move the status back
Unsigned evidenceA linked check passed, nobody signed itFill Signed off by on that ITP item
Not claimedNo claim, and no signed passNothing, until the work is checked
Evidence exceeds claimSigned pass, requirement never advancedSet the requirement to Verified
WithdrawnThe requirement was rejectedNothing. It is out of scope for verification
SubstantiatedClaimed verified, backed by a signed passNothing

What counts as evidence

•

A pass with a name in Signed off by, on an ITP item linked to the requirement. Nothing else substantiates a claim.

•

Pending and N/A results never count. Neither does a signed pass on a different requirement, including a child of this one.

•

Trace links of any kind are not evidence. The link that counts is the ITP item's Requirement validated.

•

Only Verified claims verification. Implemented reads as built but not verified, which at handover is still a gap.

What is outside

•

Archived requirements and archived ITP items.

•

Heading and information rows, which make no claim and carry no verdict.

Reading the register

The verification register, grouped worst first, with two groups open.

The verification register, grouped worst first, with two groups open.

•

The tiles count each verdict. Hover one for its definition.

•

Groups are ordered worst first and start closed. Click a group to open its requirements.

•

Checks counts the ITP items linked to that requirement, passed or not.

•

A fail outranks a pass on a sibling item, and Withdrawn outranks everything.

The three numbers to act on

The report and the Packs card keep these apart rather than adding them up:

•

Contradicted: something was checked and failed.

•

Unbacked: claimed verified with nothing signed behind it (Unsubstantiated plus Unsigned evidence).

•

Unclaimed: nobody has got to it yet.